Graham Cracker Ice Cream

Graham Cracker Infused Ice Cream! @dessertfortwo

I don’t think I’ve had a dessert that wasn’t frozen in ages.  Wait, that’s not true.  I inhaled most things in the Tartine window.  But I don’t think I’ve made a non-frozen dessert in my own kitchen in quite a long time.  Glass jars of local heavy cream just keep making their way into my fridge.  I repeatedly make plans to bake a hot berry cobbler, pour cold cream on top, and then eat the entire bowl while moaning.  However, the cream keeps jumping into my ice cream maker instead.  I don’t know how it gets there, I swear!  At this point, I can feel the dog judging me for making ice cream before 8am.

Have you heard of Christina Tosi’s wonderful dessert invention cereal milk?  The great and lovely Christina (are all dessert wizards named Christina?–YES) soaks our favorite childhood cereals in milk.  After a pinch of salt, a touch more sugar and straining, she serves it cold.  I’ve never had the pleasure of going to Momofuku for her desserts, but it’s on my bucket list.  The fruity pebbly cereal milk is the loveliest shade of peach.  Captain Crunch makes a pale yellow cereal milk.  It’s equal parts adorable and genius.  As if it couldn’t get any better, sometimes she churns it into ice cream.  Cereal milk ice cream!  My brain goes wild with ideas of things to infuse in milk.  We’re not big cereal eaters in this house, but graham cracker eaters, we are—especially the cinnamon ones!  (Not-so-shameless plug of my Graham Cracker Fried Chicken here).

I love Tosi’s version of cereal milk ice cream because it doesn’t rely on eggs.  Would you really want an egg-y flavor in your cereal milk? No way!  To ensure the ice cream stays soft, she uses gelatin.  I took it a step further and stirred in a touch of PHILADELPHIA Cream Cheese.  This way, the ice cream can last overnight in the freezer while staying soft and scoop-able.  Although, David Leite’s interview with Tossi mentions that ‘any restaurant that gives a damn will melt any unserved ice cream and re-churn the next day because freshly churned tastes best.’  I love her sentiment, but I also love that I can make this ice cream a day in advance.

This ice cream couldn’t be easier to make.  If you can pour milk over cereal, you can make this!

Graham Cracker Custard @dessertfortwo

Nabisco Honey Maid Cinnamon Graham Crackers soak in milk for 20 minutes.  They eventually dissolve into the milk.  After straining, stir in the cream, brown sugar, salt, gelatin, and cream cheese.  See the recipe below for complete instructions.

You can find all of the ingredients to make this at Safeway. And you can also win a $100 store gift card by entering in their Summer Sweepstakes. There are five winners a day from August 5th through September 5th. Enter here now!

Graham Cracker Ice Cream! @dessertfortwo

5.0 from 2 reviews
Graham Cracker Ice Cream
Prep time
Total time
yield: 1 pint
Serves: 2
  • 1 sleeve of Nabisco Honey Maid Cinnamon Graham Crackers (~12 whole crackers)
  • 1 ½ cups whole milk
  • ½ teaspoon powdered gelatin
  • 2 ounces Philadelphia Cream Cheese
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • ¼ teaspoon kosher salt
  • ¼ cup packed light brown sugar
  1. In a medium bowl, add the graham crackers. Pour the whole milk on top, and stir until the graham crackers break down. Let stand for 20 minutes. The graham crackers will fully dissolve.
  2. Meanwhile, add the gelatin to a small bowl, and pour 1 tablespoon of cool water on top. Stir until dissolved and let sit for 5 minutes.
  3. In another small bowl, add the cream cheese and microwave it until very soft and beginning to melt. Stir this into the gelatin.
  4. Pour the graham cracker mixture through a fine sieve, and press the mixture gently against the sieve to extract all of the milk. Stir in the cream, salt and brown sugar. Finally, stir in the gelatin-cream cheese mixture. Whisk this mixture very well to dissolve the brown sugar and gelatin.
  5. Pour into an ice cream maker and freeze according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Mine took 15 minutes to freeze into an almost solid mass.
  6. Serve the mixture immediately, or freeze for 30 minutes to firm up slightly. Serve with extra cinnamon graham crackers if you like.

This post is sponsored by Safeway, Inc. They provided me with certain brands of ingredients, and paid for my recipe development skillz. All opinions, words, photos, and ideas in this post are my own. Thanks for letting me partner with brands to help keep the lights on ‘round this place 😉

Source :


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.