As a sophomore in college, my three roommates and I decided to bake sweet treats for all of our friends’ birthdays in our apartment complex. However, we never actually delivered them on time. We were usually just a few days late, but one guy received his almost two months after his special day!
We said it was because we lived in the “Delayed Reaction” apartment, where the TV took a minute to turn on, the internet needed a few extra seconds to start up, and the microwave always started a good twenty seconds after you pressed start. So we were just following suit! Everyone laughed when we arrived carrying plates of cookies on their doorsteps, and they never minded our “Delayed Reaction.” It meant that they could celebrate their birthday for at least a week!
We always tried to slyly ask people’s roommates what their favorite cookies were since those wouldn’t compete with the typical birthday cakes. With the first person’s birthday coming up, his roommate revealed that his favorite cookies were pumpkin chocolate chip, and I thought that was the strangest combination ever.
Pumpkin? A vegetable? With… Chocolate??
But I baked them anyway, and we split two extra cookies between the four of us girls to sample. Oh my goodness! The sweet pumpkin… The warm cinnamon… The rich chocolate… I nearly swore on the spot to always include pumpkin in the chocolate chip cookies from then on!
Yet the problem with pumpkin cookies is that they often turn out cakey, not quite as soft and chewy as regular chocolate chip cookies. So this past month, I set out to create the Ultimate Healthy Soft & Chewy Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies. After six different batches, I finally did it!
The dry ingredients are fairly straight forward (well, minus the cornstarch twist. It helps keep the cookies chewy—read about it here or just trust me on that!). On the other hand, the wet ingredients required some testing and tweaking, especially the pumpkin purée.
Pumpkin purée contains a lot of moisture, which dries out baked goods and leaves them cakey. However, it can also act as a binding agent to hold the cookie dough together. Eggs do the same thing: add lots of moisture and bind cookies together. To balance that out, Iomitted the egg and used all pumpkin purée instead. This kept the cookies soft and maximized the pumpkin flavor.
To make the cookies chewy, I used melted butter. Unlike regular softened butter, melted really helps increase the chewy factor. This means you can put away your mixer—no butter and sugar to cream!
For slightly healthier cookies, I turned to agave, an unrefined sweetener, instead of granulated sugar. I used light agave, and it can be found on the baking aisle near the other sugars. Because agave is a liquid, it makes the cookie dough really moist and tacky, so you must chill the dough before baking. Chilling is mandatory. Only 30 minutes—just enough time to wash the dishes and wipe up any spilled flour.
Now that your cookie dough is chilling, you’re probably wondering… Why did I use miniature chocolate chips? I prefer lots of littler bursts of chocolate over just one or two bites containing big chocolate chips. Their smaller size also helps ensure that the cookie dough binds together better and doesn’t break apart in your hands while eating. That’s always a plus, especially if you’re dunking them in milk!
Because the cookie dough will still be somewhat tacky after chilling, do not try to shape it with your hands. Use a cookie scoop or a spatula to shape it into rounded mounds. If you prefer extra thick cookies, make sure they’re as tall as they are wide. If you prefer wider and thinner cookies, flatten them just a bit before popping them in the oven.
To ensure the cookies stay soft and chewy, we’ll underbake them just a tiny bit; then leave them on the warm baking sheet for at least 10 minutes to allow the centers to set and finish baking. This gives them the most irresistible texture—if you can wait long enough for them to cool!
So there you have it! The Ultimate Healthy Soft & Chewy Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies, in all of their cozy fall glory. Packed full of pumpkin and lots of decadent chocolate, they taste like pure comfort food—not healthy at all!
I sent a batch with my guy when he visited his friend, and he said that in the 30 seconds it took him to run out to his car and walk back inside his friend’s house, four of the cookies had already disappeared from the bag. Four whole cookies!
That’s the best compliment a baker could ask for. ♥
The Ultimate Healthy Soft & Chewy Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies
The classic combination of pumpkin and chocolate chips is absolutely irresistible, especially when combined together in soft and chewy cookies! Store any leftovers in an airtight container.
- In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, cornstarch, cinnamon, and salt. In a separate bowl, whisk together the butter, pumpkin, and vanilla. Stir in the agave. Add the flour mixture, stirring just until incorporated. Fold in 2 tablespoons of chocolate chips. Chill the cookie dough for at least 30 minutes. (If chilling longer than 1 hour, cover the top of the bowl with foil.)
- Preheat the oven to 325°F, and line a baking sheet with parchment paper or a silicone baking mat.
- Drop the cookie dough into 12 rounded scoops onto the prepared baking sheet. Flatten slightly, and press the remaining chocolate chips into the tops of the cookie dough. Bake at 325°F for 15-17 minutes. Cool on the baking sheet for at least 10 minutes before turning out onto a wire rack.
Notes: This cookie dough spreads a little, but not very much. If you prefer wider and thinner cookies, flatten the dough a little more before baking. (Flatten to no less than half of the rounded scoops’ original heights.)
Regular whole wheat flour or all-purpose flour may be substituted in place of the whole wheat pastry flour.
Granulated sugar may be substituted in place of the agave. However, when made with granulated sugar, the cookie dough does not spread at all while baking, so you will need to flatten the rounded scoops of cookie dough on the baking sheets before placing in the oven. They’re generally done baking in about 13-15 minutes instead.
For a vegan version, substitute melted coconut oil in place of the butter.
Do NOT overbake these cookies! They’ll turn out cakey instead of chewy if baked for too long.
Source : amyshealthybaking